Recent Stray Thoughts
If You Think You Are a Person, You've Been Had
The title above is a quote from Alan Watts. One might feel this seems intended to cajole...
Christmas and New Year Reflections and Wishes
This time of year, I can't help but notice how far much of Christianity has deviated from the...
A frequent topic in discussion groups about awakening is whether or not there is a self and if...
The Beginning and End of Searching
When did you first start searching for answers? When did you first realize that you weren't seeing the...
- If You Think You Are a Person, You've Been Had Barry (Spirituality) 2017-12-30 05:47:05
What Can Happen to Love After Awakening
In 2006, I was asked by the abbot of the retreat center I was attending to host meditation groups...
What Thirteen Year Olds Think About
My son and I spent the day in San Francisco yesterday. Driving back, as we were leaving the...
Stages of Awakening
What does it mean to awaken? Are we awakening from something or are we awakening to something? In...
- What Can Happen to Love After Awakening Barry (Spirituality) 2017-11-25 18:40:45
To Self or Not to Self
It has been said that words bind the boundless. One way in which that is true: Many traditions...
Union and Salvation
There seems to be a cyclical pattern inherent in all religions that brings about the decline of...
- To Self or Not to Self Barry (Spirituality) 2017-07-03 21:10:34
Nothing So Charming as the Present
An old college buddy asked, "If the present is so charming, why does my mind wander away from the...
Varieties of Enlightenment
Back in the mid-seventies I was in the Air Force, and was stationed on Pope Air Force Base near...
- Nothing So Charming as the Present Barry (Spirituality) 2010-08-06 22:48:00
- Written by Barry
- Category: Religion
- Hits: 753
This time of year, I can't help but notice how far much of Christianity has deviated from the teaching of Christ. Instead of seeing Christ in the poor, the sick, the imprisoned, Christians have externalized Christ into idol of worship. This externalization of Christ as the only Son of God, a divine persona in unity with God but separate from us is the exact opposite of what Jesus taught according to the Gospels.
I recently asked in a post simply, "What is aware?" A Christian friend, to my surprise, seemed to indicate that it is the Holy Spirit that is aware and asked me what my experience of the Holy Spirit is, which prompted the following reply.
"My experience of the Holy Spirit is as Presence and as Providence. When Jesus said the Holy Spirit would always be with us as Comforter, he was absolutely right. Where modern Christianity has gone wrong is they have externalized the Father, the Son, the Holy Spirit, which are symbols of complete unity of absolute and relative awareness. This awareness is not separate, was never separate and can never be separate from the present moment. Surrendering to God is surrendering to the Divine Presence that can only be in the here and now. Resting in this Divine Presence is the Oneness that Jesus welcomed us all to share in the Gospel of John. It's the Kingdom of Heaven buried in a field, that once found, we let go of everything to own that field. The field is pure awareness, right here, right now. Once one sees that, the words of Jesus begin to make complete sense. Bread and wine are the body and blood of Jesus Christ because he was in unity with all creation, with no sense of separation. Loving neighbor as self is easy when you see there is no separate self and therefore, no separation. We are all one, even as Jesus and the Father are one. This is exactly what Jesus called us to discover in the Gospel of John."
My friend then asked what I meant by "externalized." I feel my reply is worth sharing.
"'Externalized' means they see God as separate, Holy Spirit as separate, Christ as separate, when Jesus was pointing to the total lack of separation, the complete oneness and lived unity, which he clearly was inviting us to share, not when we die and are with him in heaven, but here and now.
This is not a conceptual unity as in we are all independent, individual members bound together by common beliefs. This definitely is not what Jesus was pointing to when he invited us to share in oneness with God, and not what he lived. He lived total and complete unity from the core of his being with not only God but the entire creation. And this is the Oneness he invited us to experience and live.
He saw no separateness, not in anything or anyone. To look within, to find the kingdom of heaven at hand, to see the face of Christ in the poor, the sick, the imprisoned, the Jews and gentiles, the Samaritans and the prostitutes, to see the Providence that provides equally for all, the birds and all animals, and arrays even the lilies of the field in splendor finer than any garment Solomon ever wore, to see one’s body in bread and one’s blood in wine, to care for the sick and impoverished, this is the embodied Oneness that is living in the non-separate Presence that is the Holy Spirit and is our very awareness, 'if we have eyes to see and ears to hear.'
It is not a club or congregation or cult of beliefs, but a directly experienced, lived reality. Do you see the difference?"
Given the way Christ's teaching has been distorted and turned upside down, it is no wonder how we now have so many Christians that support political parties that have policies in direct opposition to Christ's teachings. The perversion of Christianity foreshadowed the rise of a US government that, quietly at first and now blatantly, transformed a congress of the people, by the people and for the people into a corrupt body of representatives of, by and for corporations and billionaires. To treat corporations as special entities with lower tax rates can only mean that tax paying individuals are now here to pay for the infrastructure from which these corporations and their shareholders benefit. The tax savings will be funneled to shareholders and only to employees after all other considerations are addressed. Tax payers are asked to pay for "defense", which is the largest network of military bases the world has ever known, which are called on to do the bidding of the congressmen clearly representing the interests of corporations, not tax paying citizens.
And how will we pay for this $1.5 trillion welfare program for corporations and billionaires? It will be through cutting the very programs that care for the poor, the sick, the elderly and rehabilitate the imprisoned. Yet right-wing Christians gladly support this. Not only do they fail to see the face of Christ in the underprivileged, they turn their backs on them out of callous greed and indignant self-righteousness. This is not the Christianity that represents the teaching of Jesus. It is far from the Oneness he embodied.
As we reflect on the birth of a being that was one with all things, the coming of the light that destroys delusion born of darkness, we should all look within to find the light that made Jesus proclaim, "You are the light of the world."
I pray that we are guided by this light that sees unity in all things as we enter this New Year and that this is reflected in the choices we make at the polls in our elections in 2018 and 2020.
Wishing you holidays of peace and joy and the light of Unity throughout the New Year!
- Written by Barry
- Category: Meditation
- Hits: 944
In 2007, I was on a Vipassana retreat led by Ven. Chanmyay Sayadaw and learned to practice walking meditation in a new way. On these retreats, the participants alternate between an hour of sitting meditation and an hour of slow walking meditation for 18 hours a day. Ven. Chanmyay emphasized unbroken mindfulness, such that one is fully present with whatever one is doing during as long as one is conscious. As it turns out, there can be lucidity even during sleeping and dreaming. Awareness is inseparable from the silence inherent in the present and is that silence and presence. Even though the body sleeps, there is an underlying continuum of awareness and lucidity during dreams. So, there can be unbroken mindfulness throughout the day.
The practices of walking meditation and mindfulness, as taught in the Theravada tradition, may make use of "labeling" or noting what is happening as it actually happens. Each step of walking meditation is divided at first into three parts, lifting, pushing and dropping, as in lifting the heel, pushing the foot forward through space, and dropping (lowering) the foot. After two or three days of this, Ven. Chanmyay would have the "yogis", as he called us, further divide and label the process of walking into six phases, lifting (the heel), raising (the foot), pushing, dropping (lowering), touching and pressing (shifting weight onto the foot). After a couple days of doing this, Ven. Chanmyay, during a daily interview with him, instructed me to shift awareness to the impulse to lift the foot, to find the point when the impulse to lift the foot arises in consciousness.
By that time, remaining fully present was fluid and effortless. Attention was laser-like. Silence was all enveloping. As I began the practice of noting the impulse to lift the heel arising, the practice completely transformed. I was out walking on the ground that had been blessed by monks squatting down and chanting on every square foot of where the new vihara would be constructed, as is their tradition, mainly because the grass wasn't high there. After a couple sessions of sitting and walking meditation, as I was being mindful of the impulse to lift the heel, suddenly the leg raised up high as if trying to step over a big log, yet there was nothing else present other than the feeling of surprise. The foot came down and there was looking for the next impulse to raise the foot and again, the leg, "involuntarily" raised up much higher than necessary. This continued for several minutes. There was no control over it, nothing there to be in control over it. Just looking and the impulse coming out of silence and the phenomena of the exaggerated lifting of the foot.
Eventually, this settled down but later, the ground became like water, as if rippling and walking on water. There was no sense of separation between the awareness of this fluid nature of the ground, the walking, the ground and environment. Everything seemed to collapse into waves with nothing but awareness waving as body, air, ground.
During my next interview with Ven. Chanmyay, he simply said, "This is the realization of no self." With regard to the fluid, waving nature of earth, he said it was the direct perception of the element, vayu, air or wind, brought about through experience of motion from walking meditation.
After that three week retreat, walking was never the same again. Walking has been instant entry into the silence inherent in motion, where all time falls away and there is only vast spaciousness.
On a subsequent Chan retreat in 2008 in upstate New York, it was experienced differently. There, walking meditation is practiced without noting or labeling. Casual walking around the Chan hall, the timekeeper has participants gradually slow the pace and then begin slow walking meditation. After maybe 20 minutes of this, the xiangban, the incense board that timekeeper uses to whack people with traditionally (no longer practiced in there), is struck to the floor and the timekeeper yells, "STOP!" During one such occurrence, everything fell away, the walking, the body, the room. There was only soft, vacuous light. The only thing present seemed to be some kind of substanceless particles gently descending in that silence, nothing else, no sense of seer, experiencer, doer, perceiver. Just a knowing of light-filled spaciousness.
In the Theravada tradition, specifically Burmese Mahasi Sayadaw tradition (Ven. Chanmyay, or U Janaka, was one of Mahasi Sayadaw's senior students), mindfulness is practiced at the juncture of samadhi, referred to as access or gateway samadhi. In Samatha, or calming, meditation, one develops the ability to experience the Jhanas, or levels of samadhi. In Vipassana, or insight, meditation, one settles to the point of transcendence but does not become absorbed into full samadhi. At this juncture or cusp between waking state and samadhi, awareness is as settled as it can be while still functioning. In the Tibetan Dzogchen tradition, this is referred to as Rigpa, primordial, pure awareness. In the Chan tradition, this is referred to as Mind. Regardless of the tradition or the label we refer to it, it is devoid of any sense of identity. It is the complete absence of separateness. It is the complete knowing without reference to knower or known. Buddha-Nature. Suchness. It is the completeness found in each moment, perfect without lack. Just so.
When life becomes lived from Suchness, life flows. All worries, apprehensions, fears, cravings, dissatisfactions fall away. All desire to promote oneself over others dissolves. All sense of separateness evaporates. Entanglement in thought ceases. Thoughts come and go as normal, spontaneous function of mind but don't pose obstructions or cause vexations. This is abiding freedom, clarity, transparency, natural response manifesting as wisdom, kindness, altruistic joy, and deep equanimity. It is just what is when there is complete letting go. It is also the letting go and the not letting go. There is no separation. All things resolve in this. It is before thinking mind but thinking mind is not separate. It's the silence overlaid with worries and the worries. There is nothing that is beyond this. It is all things, all states, and the absence of states. It is what is.
To see this, sometimes we need to spend time with a practice that sets up the conditions for letting go and direct seeing. Or, for some, it can come about through direct inquiry and investigation, not as an intellectual pursuit but as direct seeing, looking at what is aware, looking directly at being here and now, seeing here and now, unceasingly looking until all seeking is resolved in the silence of the present, clear, bright, open, naturally loving awareness that has always been here, whether walking, talking, dreaming, eating, thinking, doing or not doing. It is just this what is here right now, now never fixed, timeless.
After reading this, I would be interested in what you think of this video.
- Written by Barry
- Category: Meditation
- Hits: 1392
What does it mean to awaken? Are we awakening from something or are we awakening to something? In a mundane sense, when we awaken, we are awakening from the sleep cycle of dreaming and deep sleep, to the conscious waking state. In a spiritual sense, we are not awakening from the waking state to another state, but are awakening from states. The body and brain still go through states. But, mind becomes free of states. Although, there may be a time when we "awaken", a sudden transition and transformation that happens in time, the awakening is not in time or space. People relate stories about their awakening, how it came about, what it was like, what life has been like since the initial awakening. But, this has little to do with awakened mind, awakened awareness. This is just the relative story. People that are not yet awakened hear these stories and start looking for experiences. But, the experiences are not the awakening. The awakening is what was there before the experiences and stories and what remains after the experiences and stories.
Before awakening, we are in a kind of union with what we are doing. We loose self awareness and get absorbed in the activity of the day. As people practice meditation, they find that there is silence behind all the more turbulent aspects of mind, not a dead silence but bare, baseline awareness. It is unowned. It is not my awareness or your awareness but pervasive, omnipresent. Once pure awareness is clearly seen, it cannot be unseen. It may fade, be temporarily forgotten as we habitually react to life as we were accustomed before awakening. But, that pure awareness is indelible once seen. It becomes clear that it is the very foundation of life and the medium of all relative experience.
If this awake awareness is always there, why aren't we naturally aware of it? How often are we aware of our noses? How often do we notice our eyes blinking? Our heart beating, our breath? We notice things when they change. When air suddenly becomes warmer or cooler, we suddenly notice air, that we are living within a gaseous atmosphere. We otherwise don't notice it unless suddenly deprived of it. Through change, phenomena are noticed. What is silent, omnipresent, unchanging, our very essence is completely overlooked.
So, how was this awareness discovered? Whether we look to the Upanishads, the Dao De Jing, Buddhist Sutras, the Bhagavad Gita, the Yoga Sutras, mysticism or Native spirituality, there are always two things that are present for awakening to occur:
1. A settled mind.
2. Open clarity.
When conditions are such that the mind is calm and settles, thoughts naturally subside. But, for awakening to occur, there must also be an open, receptive clarity. It is not a catatonic state, but calm clarity. It is what is there when there is pure, direct observation before any associations, analysis, opinions or commentary form in the mind. We may first notice this as clear, silent awareness we experience in meditation, or when we are rapt by a sunset, in the presence of a ancient tree, swimming laps, or sketching a landscape. In meditation, there can be times when there appear to be gaps in the continuity of time and space, when we are not sleeping, but momentarily transcend all experience. Certain meditation methods help explore and clarify these periods of transcendence. But, if when through with meditation, our mind returns to its habitual reactive state, it can take many years for the silence of meditation to find its way into day-to-day waking life. Initially, we need to remind ourselves to pause, to not react, to let go and be with whatever is arising.
Through mindfulness of our mental and emotional states and settled clarity about what is actually happening, the silent clarity we fine in meditation becomes the conscious baseline awareness throughout the day. As this silent awareness becomes predominant, it can feel like a silent witnessing, like awareness is seeing through the portals of the eyes, hearing through the ears. Initially, it can feel very localized, like one is riding in one's head peering out through the senses at an external phenomenal world that is separate from this silent witness. It's very much a state of duality, where inner silence experiences all activities of the day. One may feel extraordinarily content, even blissful. You may even feel this has become a permanent transformation and that you have "awakened." And this is an awakening -- an initial awakening to pure awareness as it starts to become embodied in day-to-day life. But, this isn't complete. It's a partial truth. One can still be very self-centered in this state, perhaps maximally self-centered. While it is true that when we feel self-content, we may be more free to care for others, it doesn't always play out that way. Some people can become quite reclusive when they find themselves to be the silent witness of all they perceive and that self-awareness becomes quite deep. It doesn't necessarily activate the heart. Sometimes people can become quite aloof, distant during this early phase of awakening. In the worst case, they can even become dysfunctional, have problems in their relationships and become dissociated. This is not liberation. This is where it really helps to have a good teacher that has been through this and has seen other people go through it. People can get stuck here for a long time without a better map or clear instruction.
It's important to note that some may spontaneously start experiencing life as a silent witness without ever learning to meditate or without ever having an interest in spiritual development. I remember periods as a child when I felt like I was riding in a mechanical structure very much like the imperial stormtroopers that ride inside the head of those four legged tanks in Star Wars episodes. I had intense self-awareness and the accompanying sense of separation from what is perceived. I remember when I was in the Air Force and would drive out to Cape Hatteras on Friday night and lay out on the beach at night, I would experience a state of restful alertness that would last for hours and upon rising with the sun, was bright, silent awareness experiencing the world. I'm sure many people have had such periods of clarity. But, this is a very dualistic state, a state of silent separateness. It can be a very self-content, blissful state, but it is a kind of one-sided awakening. We have awakened from a state where we were largely not self-aware to a state where self-awareness never seems to leave, even in dreams and even in dreamless sleep. If one dreams, there is clarity that one is dreaming. If the body turns in the middle of the night, initially it can be quite jarring and surprising, as if rolling inside a dark log in the middle of the night. All this evens out with time.
As mentioned, one of the pitfalls of this stage is to think that one is enlightened and finished with the path. Or worse, that one is ready to teach others. People can get trapped here. And in spite of all the non-dual speak about there not being a person, there is very much a person in this state. Both negative and positive egoic tendencies can still be quite active, though they are witnessed coming and going. Such a person can still be very caught up in narrative stories about why they "must" do this or that or excuses why they continue to do this or that. With time, these begin to be seen through.
And with time, due to the increasing clarity of perception and calmness of mind, things in the external world are seen more as they actually are and less through associative filtering, historical biases. There is a more direct seeing and through this seeing, insights about mental, emotional and the external physical world can occur. One fundamental insight is impermanence. All mental, emotional and physical states are constantly changing. The contrast between inner silent awareness and outer states can be quite pronounced during this period. On a Vipassana retreat in Springfield, Illinois, I once had the feeling that the world was like a burning building and I was inside it. My perception had become so sharp and laser-like during this retreat that I could take in all the sounds of birds chirping, mosquito buzzing, cars tires on asphalt, wind through trees, the sun on my face and it all translated into a deep sense that everything changing with dizzying speed, as if undergoing rapid oxidation. The entire world seemed to be burning with such rapid, uncontrolled change. And yet my mind was completely serene. During this phase, one can become very dispassionate. Relationships can suffer unless there is awareness with both partners what is happening and that "this too shall pass." My marriage suffered greatly during this period and finally ended in 2010 largely due to this dispassionate period that happened years before.
There can also be periods where the world is seen as a reflection of the inner silence. One becomes entranced by the simplest things. The natural world especially takes on a sublime beauty and grace that was previously missed. During this phase, relationships can be incredibly blissful. Sexual relationships can be absolutely incredible. Orgasms become rapturous, intense and prolonged. It becomes easy to fall in love with everyone and everything. Little-by-little, or all at once, the intense separation felt during earlier stages of awakening falls away. The silence once experienced internally as self, is now perceived out there in the world looking back at you. And there is an intuition and then a full blown realization that the silence out there is not different than the internal awareness. Or, it can happen in a kind of cataclysmic fashion where all separation just drops away in an instant. Once, while on a Chan retreat in New York state, I was practicing direct contemplation and was observing a big boulder out by a pond. Suddenly, awareness completely pivoted and I was no longer looking out at the world but the world was all awareness, like a cosmic symphony of cause and effect, but not in a dead Newtonian way, but a vibrant, live answering of all that came before, all things joyfully aware of the calling, all things the perfect answer. During that retreat, the separateness of self and other just evaporated away. Everything is perfect in its own right and all interactions between wind and leaves, water and rocks, sunlight reflecting of leaves and waves, everything utterly perfect and inseparable. And with this, the recognition that this body and being were part and parcel of the entire symphony of ubiquitous living awareness. During the ten hour drive home from that retreat, I was the car, I was the road, I was all other cars flowing as a school of fish, all conscious, all aware, all flowing in time but riding in such silence, inching our way across the surface of such a glorious planet, our living, intimate home.
When unity unfolds, it can be very blissful indeed. We feel at home no matter where we are. Nothing is foreign, everything is fascinating, nothing is none of our business. This is a time of vision and enterprise. We can feel that we have the blessing of Mother Earth, of the moon, sun and stars, of the entire universe. We can begin to feel that we are the grace that has blessed us. We can feel drawn to help others, save them from their limited thinking. We can become politically active, seeing things so much clearer than ever before, we feel drawn to lead and influence the direction locally and globally. We naturally think globally for the planet is not separate. There is only awareness. Consciousness. The universe is alive, is Life, and we are that Life!
As with all the other stages, this stage too can have it's downside. One can take on a bodhisattva identity, a savior identity. Compassion can become intense. We suddenly can feel what others are feeling with such depth and clarity and see so clearly why they are suffering we feel compelled to help them! Life doesn't have to be like that! Some even begin to think that they are on a mission from God and that they are God, by the way. An avatar here to deliver others from delusion! But, unless they see through these identities, they will only be leading others into the same enlightened delusion they are unwittingly suffering from.
And then, it can happen that suddenly all identification vanishes in an instant. Suddenly, there is a total absence of self-reference. There isn't even a thought that there is such an absence! A sudden, open, vacuousness. A complete dissolution of ownership, the concept of "my" or "mine", of localized awareness. The center disappears. Before, when one was feeling all one with everything, there was still a center that was localized in space and time that felt one with everything else in space and time, it all backed by silence. But now, that localization disappears and the relating to all things as one disappears. There is a complete falling away of any imagined identity, whether as a professional, a bodhisattva, a guru or avatar. There is utter and complete humility and not even that because there is nothing to be humbled. This can happen in stages. The first time, it can feel like you are on the edge of an unfathomable crevasse and can take your breath away. You gasp and back away thinking, "What will become of me?" Fear is still binding you. It can happen again but this time you are more prepared and find yourself in a free fall with no turning back. And at that point, there is no self-reference. Nothing is falling, nothing is disappearing, nothing, nothing, nothing. Yet perfect silence. All things resolved in this silence. Much ado about nothing. Vacuousness. And yet, not empty.
Emptiness, and yet not devoid of anything. The great resolution. Nothing unresolved. Perfect peace. An end to striving. An end to fear. Nothing more to do.
And yet, life continues. We are still in relationships. We still do work. We still try to take care of others needs. We still get hungry. We still pay bills. Others still have expectations of us. We are still in the world. Initially, this can be a very disorienting time unless it happens gradually in increments giving time to acclimate to being in the world in this new, ancient way.
This all happens quite naturally. No amount of intellectual contrivance can bring it about any faster than it will occur from simple meditation practice coupled with mindfulness practice. But, understanding how it unfolds and what some of the pitfalls are along the way can save a lot of time and suffering of self and others. Understanding milestones can help save relationships worth saving but otherwise in jeopardy. Hope this might help inspire practice and prevent getting caught up. This is the way I see it at this point based on what has happened. Others may see it differently. Don't take my word for it. Find out for yourself. <3
Page 3 of 3